Stacked vs. Unstacked Car Insurance: Which One Saves You More?

26 Aug, 2025 . 9 days ago
Banner Blog

If you're shopping for auto insurance in Brentwood, CA, you’ve probably come across the terms stacked and unstacked car insurance. They might sound technical, but the difference between them could have a big impact on your coverage — and your wallet.

This post will break down what these two terms mean, how they apply in California (yes, there’s a twist), and how to make sure you’re saving money without sacrificing the protection you need.

First, What Is Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage?

Before we get into stacked vs. unstacked insurance, let’s talk about the coverage they apply to.

Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM) coverage kicks in when:

  • You're hit by a driver who doesn't have insurance.
  • You're hit by a driver who doesn’t have enough insurance to cover your medical bills or damages.
  • You're involved in a hit-and-run accident.

It’s optional in California, but incredibly valuable — especially when you consider that millions of drivers in the state are either uninsured or underinsured.

What Is “Stacked” Car Insurance?

Stacked insurance means you can combine (or "stack") your UM/UIM coverage limits across multiple vehicles on your policy. This increases your potential payout if you're in an accident caused by an uninsured or underinsured driver.

Example:

Say you have two cars, and each has $30,000 per person/$60,000 per accident in UM/UIM coverage. If you stack your policy, you can double your limit:

  • $60,000 per person / $120,000 per accident

That’s a huge upgrade in protection — without doubling your premium.

What Is “Unstacked” Car Insurance?

Unstacked insurance means each vehicle’s coverage is treated separately. You can only use the limits of the vehicle involved in the accident.

Using the same example:

  • You have two cars with $30,000/$60,000 in UM/UIM coverage.
  • If you’re hit while driving one of them, that’s all the coverage you get — you can’t pull from the other car’s policy.

Unstacked coverage is more limited but usually comes with lower premiums.

Does California Allow Stacked Insurance?

Here’s where it gets interesting.

California does not allow stacking of uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.

That means whether you insure one vehicle or five, your UM/UIM coverage cannot be combined. Your maximum payout is limited to the coverage listed on the specific vehicle involved in the accident.

So, why talk about it?

If you’re relocating from another state or managing multi-state policies, it’s still crucial to understand. Plus, many insurance companies use the stacked/unstacked framework in their marketing — even in states where stacking isn’t allowed.

How to Think About “Stacking” Strategically in California

Even though you can’t legally stack coverage in California, there are creative, smart ways to structure your policy to get similar benefits.

Here’s how:

Increase Your UM/UIM Limits

Since you can’t combine coverage, make sure the coverage on each vehicle is high enough to protect you in a worst-case scenar

Remember, the new minimum auto insurance limits in California (as of Jan 1, 2025) are:

  • $30,000 for bodily injury per person
  • $60,000 for bodily injury per accident
  • $15,000 for property damage per accident

These are just the minimums — they may not be enough to cover serious injuries or multiple passengers.

Ensure all Household Drivers are Properly

Many people assume that coverage automatically extends to every driver in the home. It doesn’t.

To maximize protection, make sure all licensed drivers in your household are listed on your policy — and that each of their vehicles has robust UM/UIM coverage.

Ask About Multi-Vehicle Discounts

Even though stacking isn’t allowed, bundling multiple cars on the same policy can lead to lower rates and better coverage options.

A knowledgeable agent in Brentwood can help you balance high coverage limits with cost-saving opportunities.

Consider an Umbrella Policy

A personal umbrella policy provides extra liability coverage that kicks in after your standard auto policy limits are exhausted. It’s a great backup plan and can often be added for a small monthly cost.

Does Stacked Insurance Save Money?

Technically, stacked coverage costs more, but gives you significantly better protection if it’s available.

In states like Pennsylvania or Florida, it can be a lifesaver. In California, though, since stacking isn’t permitted, the real “money-saving” decision comes down to:

  • Choosing the right limits
  • Avoiding redundant or unnecessary coverage
  • Working with an agent who understands California’s rules

How to Choose the Best Auto Insurance in Brentwood, CA

If you live in Brentwood or the greater Contra Costa County area, you know California drivers face unique risks: wildfires, earthquake-prone regions, heavy traffic corridors, and uninsured motorists.

Here’s how to choose the right policy — stacked or not:

Work With a Local Broker

Unlike big-name national insurers, local insurance brokers in Brentwood, CA understand the market, laws, and risks you actually face. They can recommend UM/UIM limits that reflect real-life driving conditions, not just state minimums.

Get a Free Policy Review

Insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all. At Circadian Insurance Brokers, we’ll review your current coverage and identify:

  • Gaps in liability
  • Opportunities to increase protection affordably
  • Ways to lower premiums through bundling or discounts
Don’t Focus Only on Price

Saving money is important — but not if it leaves you exposed in an accident. Instead, aim for value: strong coverage at a reasonable rate.

When you work with a broker, we’ll shop rates from multiple carriers to find the perfect balance.

Final Verdict

If you’re in a state where stacking is legal, stacked coverage is often worth the slightly higher premium for the added protection.

But in California, your focus should shift. Since stacking isn’t allowed, the smartest move is to:

  • Raise your UM/UIM limits
  • Bundle vehicles for savings
  • Customize your policy with the help of a local expert

If you’re not sure whether your current auto insurance meets the new California standards — or whether it protects you from uninsured drivers — now is the time to act.

At Circadian Insurance Brokers, we specialize in auto insurance in Brentwood CA, and we’re here to make insurance simple, smart, and affordable.

Request a free quote or policy review today. We’ll make sure you’re fully covered — and never overpaying.

Circadian Insurance Brokers — Your Local Auto Insurance Experts in Brentwood, CA